Independent Country ExpertUK
UK only. UK immigration & asylum tribunals only — for solicitors and Legal Aid practitioners in England, Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland.

Oral Evidence Country Expert UK | FTT & UT Hearings

Country experts may be directed to give oral evidence at First-tier Tribunal and Upper Tribunal hearings. The expert confirms their written report, may provide supplementary oral evidence within their area of expertise, and faces cross-examination from both parties. Independence is tested under questioning — experts must give honest answers even where they do not support the instructing party's case.

Immigration Tribunal Practice Direction 2024 governs joint expert meetings before hearings. Experts must engage genuinely, identify areas of agreement and disagreement, and must not collude. Joint statements should reflect authentic expert positions, not negotiated advocacy positions.

Solicitors should prepare experts for cross-examination by ensuring consistency between written and oral testimony, rehearsing methodology and source selection, and anticipating challenges on independence, dated sources, and assumed facts. Experts who appear partisan or unprepared damage both their credibility and the client's case.

Related Expertise

Contact Us — UK Tribunals Only

Submit your case details for confidential routing to the right jurisdiction-specific expert. UK immigration and asylum tribunals only. Response within one business day. Legal Aid compatible.

Contact UsHow to Instruct

Oral Evidence at Tribunal: Frequently Asked Questions

Do country experts give oral evidence at tribunal hearings?

Yes — where directed by the tribunal or requested by parties. The expert confirms their report, may give supplementary evidence within their expertise, and faces cross-examination. Independence is tested under questioning.

How should solicitors prepare experts for cross-examination?

Ensure consistency between written and oral testimony; rehearse methodology and source selection; anticipate challenges on independence, dated sources, and assumed facts. Experts must give honest answers even where they do not support the instructing party's case.

When does the tribunal direct oral evidence from country experts?

The tribunal may direct oral evidence in country guidance cases, where expert evidence is hotly disputed, or where written reports require clarification. Parties may also request expert attendance.

What happens at a joint expert meeting?

Under Practice Direction 2024, experts meet before hearing to identify agreement and disagreement. Meetings must be genuine — not collusion. Joint statements reflect authentic expert positions.

Can experts give evidence beyond their written report?

Experts may give supplementary oral evidence within their area of expertise but must not introduce new opinions not foreshadowed in the written report without tribunal permission.

What cross-examination challenges should experts expect?

Challenges on independence, source dating, assumed facts, methodology, and consistency between written and oral testimony. Experts must give honest answers even where they do not support the instructing party.